I came across this interesting social history case in the DIPPAM Archives recently. DIPPAM which stands for Documenting Ireland: Parliament, People and Migration, is an online virtual archive of documents and sources relating to the history of Ireland, and its migration experience from the 18th to the late 20th centuries.
The documents related to an event which occurred in 1879 and an inquiry was called to investigate how the Dromore West Workhouse was been managed.
A Captain Spaight, who was the Local Government Board Inspector, chaired the Inquiry, and it concerned a Miss Annie Kiolehan, who was working as the headmistress in the Dromore West Workhouse in county Sligo in the north west of Ireland in 1879.
Annie Kiolehan had given birth to a baby girl on the 24th September 1880, Annie was living and still teaching in the workhouse in the weeks leading up to the birth and she appears to have kept the pregnancy hidden until a week before the birth. As Annie was not married the baby was deemed illegitimate and after giving birth to a girl named Estella, Annie was obliged to resign from her teaching post and leave the workhouse, she left her baby under the charge of the workhouse. The birth of the baby by an employee of the workhouse caused scandal in the area and letters and articles appeared in the local press at the time. An inquiry was called for, to investigate the incident and to find out how the workhouse was been run. At the time of the birth, Miss Kiolehan had not stated who the father of the child was, a few weeks later she gave the name of the father as a Peter Hale.
Peter Hale, was the son of the Patron of the workhouse and had visited the workhouse several times. The report reveals how employees at the workhouse were frequently drunk and it was believed this gave rise to the incident.
Annie states that on New Years Eve of 31st December 1879 she had gone to bed early and woke up to find a man in her room, she then fainted and when she woke up the man was gone, she wasn’t certain at the time but thought the man looked like Peter Hale. When questioned about why she thought it was Peter Hale, Miss Kiolehan stated she had received an anonymous letter referring to the incident and how she shouldn’t report it as to not disgrace herself. She also gave evidence, stating how she was out walking one day after the incident and Peter Hale had tried to kiss her and asked her, had she anymore Midnight visitors.
Several witnesses were called to give evidence at the Inquiry, including the Chaplain at the workhouse who baptised the baby, he states he baptised the infant Estella, the Chaplain is also asked about the name Emma, which he denies knowing about. A Porter gave evidence and his entrance book was submitted as evidence, which records the coming and goings of visitors to the workhouse, as Peter Hale was related to the Patron, he wasn’t recorded in the book. The inquiry also mentions how the Master of the workhouse, a Thomas Lavelle and his wife the Matron, Mary Lavelle were frequently drunk and even while attending the Inquiry.
Peter Hale denied the accusations that he was the father of the child or that he had more than a passing acquaintance with Miss Kiolehan. Peter was the son of Richard Hale, one of the director’s on the Board of Guardians for the workhouse, he was also related to the Matron Mary Lavelle and the Medical Officer Doctor Charles Mahon. Peter Hale mentioned other men he had seen Annie walking with or talking to, one of which was her cousin Peter Wall.
The inquiry verdict
After two days of evidence, Captain Spaight recommended that the Master and Matron should resign from their posts and that Annie Kiolehan had most likely been seduced outside of the workhouse and that Peter Hale was not the father of the child. Thus ensuring the Workhouse was not held responsible.
The child remained in the workhouse and Annie offered to pay 1d 6s for the child’s upkeep, this was refused by the Board of the workhouse, who stated the child must be removed from the workhouse as the child was not sick or if the child remained, Annie would need to admit herself into the workhouse.
Annie appears to have come from a well to do family, as she mentions during her evidence how she spent 12 months in New York, after she failed a teaching exam, she was a young educated woman of about 30 years of age in 1880, who had the fare to travel and return from America in the late 1870’s and also how despite resigning from her teaching position she was offering to pay money towards her child’s upkeep. On the advice of her sister, she hired a solicitor a Mr Mannion to represent her during the Inquiry.
Reading between the lines of the inquiry report, I think Annie and Peter, had a relationship of some sort at the time, as Annie mentions lending a book called Kusheen to Peter, they appeared to be more than passing acquaintances.
I wondered after reading the report, what became of Annie and her child, I checked the census for Kiolehan, which is an unusual spelling of the surname and I found Annie/Bridget in the 1901 census and in the genealogy records, it shows the birth of Estella Kivlehan in September 1880 and then a record for Estille Hale, christened on the 4th of November 1880, her parents are listed as Annie Kivlhan and her father as Peter Hale and the place of residence is the workhouse, next to the record is the word illegitimate. and the name Emma has been inserted, which ties in with the details which came out during the inquiry.
I checked the 1901 census and can’t find a 20 year old Emma or Estille, I did find Peter Hale and his wife of twenty two years, Winifred and their four children. One of the witnesses during the inquiry, remarked how Annie was unfortunate to be seduced by such as person, where she had nothing to gain and no hope of marriage, the inference that Peter was already married. On the 1901 census, Bridget Kiolehan is listed as a retired national school teacher and was living just a few miles away from the workhouse, in what appears to be a boarding house in Templeboy, Dromore West in County Sligo.
I can’t find any other records for Emma or Estella, perhaps she was adopted and her name changed.
I was telling my mother about the case as she is originally from Dromore West and she hadn’t heard of it but she did mention, how her great grandfather had worked in the Workhouse, a William O’Hara and how they were never sure where he had come from originally as he had died young. I would love to learn more about my family connection to the Workhouse and about this case, if you have heard about it before or know more about it, do let me know.
Sources: http://www.dippam.ac.uk/ 1. Paper relating to Management and Discipline of Workhouse at Dromore West, County Sligo 2. http://www.census.nationalarchives.ie/ National Archives of Ireland 3. http://www.workhouses.org.uk/DromoreWest/ 4. Images: Pixabay.com 5. National Library of Ireland - Parish records 6. Newspaper archive - Irish Times - 16 Nov 1880